Hoover's 2025 Mayoral Race: Brocato vs. Derzis in a Battle of Public Safety Titans

August 15, 2025 - HOOVER, AL - As Hoover, Alabama prepares for its municipal election on August 26, 2025, the city's mayoral race has emerged as one of the most closely watched contests in the region. Incumbent Mayor Frank Brocato is seeking a third term, facing off against challenger Nick Derzis, Hoover's longtime police chief. Both candidates bring decades of public service experience and deep ties to the community-but offer distinct visions for Hoover's future.

The Candidates: Experience in Public Safety

Frank Brocato has served as Hoover's mayor since 2016, following a 42-year career with the Hoover Fire Department, where he rose to the rank of fire marshal. His tenure as mayor has been marked by efforts to expand economic development, improve infrastructure, and navigate crises such as the COVID-19 pandemic and periods of social unrest.

Nick Derzis, Hoover's police chief since 2005, has spent over 40 years in law enforcement, nearly all of it with the Hoover Police Department. Known for his hands-on leadership and emphasis on proactive policing, Derzis is campaigning on a platform of revitalization, transparency, and restoring Hoover's reputation as a "standard of excellence."

Public Safety: A Shared Priority

Both candidates agree that public safety is the cornerstone of effective governance. At a recent candidates' forum hosted by the Hoover Chamber of Commerce and Shelby County media outlets, Brocato emphasized that "public safety is the most important thing we do," linking it to stronger neighborhoods, better schools, and vibrant retail.

Derzis echoed the sentiment but added a sharper critique: "We've got to get this city going. We were the standard of excellence, and when I'm elected mayor, we will get that back." He stressed the need for proactive leadership and a renewed commitment to transparency and responsiveness.

Economic Development: Diverging Strategies

Brocato highlighted Hoover's recent economic wins under his administration, including the arrival of Trader Joe's, Bassmaster headquarters, and the revitalization of office space along Highway 280. He credited the city's economic development team and partnerships across Alabama for attracting diverse businesses.

Derzis, however, argued that Hoover's retail sector has declined and needs a fresh approach. "I hear the administration say Amazon and online shopping are to blame," he said, "but I disagree. My wife drags me to the Summit on Saturdays, and I can't find a parking spot." He wants Hoover to attract the "right stores" and envisions a local retail renaissance that rivals Birmingham's upscale shopping districts.

Leadership and Integrity

When asked about leadership traits, Brocato pointed to his crisis management experience and long-standing service. "I've been in the trenches," he said. "I've led through incredible situations-from social unrest to COVID-and we did it with distinction."

Derzis emphasized his command of Hoover's largest department and budget. "Being a police officer for 40 years, a police chief for over 20, I've led the largest department in the city. We've been very proactive, and it's something we're proud of."

Both candidates were asked to reflect on moments that tested their integrity. While specific anecdotes varied, each stressed the importance of principled decision-making and accountability to the public.

Transparency and Trust

Derzis has made transparency a central theme of his campaign, pledging to open lines of communication between city hall and residents. "We need leadership that listens," he said. "I want to be a mayor who's accessible and honest."

Brocato responded by pointing to his record of community engagement and open government. He cited town halls, public forums, and partnerships with local organizations as evidence of his commitment to transparency.

The Broader Election Landscape

The mayoral race is part of Hoover's broader municipal election, which includes contests for all seven city council seats. Three council members-Casey Middlebrooks, Steve McClinton, and Derrick Murphy-are running unopposed, while other seats have drawn multiple challengers.

The election is being held under Alabama's municipal election laws, with candidates required to file statements of economic interest and comply with campaign finance regulations. Voters can find full election details on the City of Hoover's official website.

What's at Stake

Hoover, Alabama's sixth-largest city, faces a pivotal moment. With a population nearing 95,000 and a reputation for strong schools, safe neighborhoods, and economic opportunity, the next mayor will shape the city's trajectory for years to come.

Issues such as retail revitalization, infrastructure investment, public safety, and civic engagement are top of mind for voters. Both Brocato and Derzis offer compelling credentials-but differ in tone, strategy, and vision.

As the August 26 election approaches, Hoover residents are encouraged to attend forums, review candidate platforms, and make their voices heard at the ballot box.